sametimenextmonth: January 2015

Wednesday, January 28, 2015

January 2015 Book Club

Book: All the Light We Cannot See Author: Anthony Doerr

Hostess: Pam Boeck

Rating:

We kicked-off the New Year at Pam Boeck’s home; warm and cozy and smelling wonderful as we gathered on a pretty chilly January night. Thanks to Don, Denise was able to be with us. She is recovering nicely from her knee surgery but not up for the long drive. Unfortunately, Arnora and Barb were feeling under the weather and Laura and Terry were out of town. The rest of us convened for a vegan sweet potato chili, green and pasta salads, bread, appetizers and two desserts! Pam made an oatmeal cake and Carla A made bread pudding with chocolate sauce. Congratulations to Darby who returned from her trip to the Bahama’s as a newly married woman! What a great trip they had and we are all excited for her new journey.

Our book this month was “All the Light We Cannot See.” NATIONAL BOOK AWARD FINALIST
by Anthony Doerr. The novel is about a blind French girl and a German boy whose paths collide in occupied France as both try to survive the devastation of World War II.

Marie-Laure lives with her father in Paris near the Museum of Natural History, where he works as the master of its thousands of locks. When she is six, Marie-Laure goes blind and her father builds a perfect miniature of their neighborhood so she can memorize it by touch and navigate her way home. When she is twelve, the Nazis occupy Paris and father and daughter flee to the walled citadel of Saint-Malo, where Marie-Laure’s reclusive great-uncle lives in a tall house by the sea. With them they carry what might be the museum’s most valuable and dangerous jewel.

In a mining town in Germany, the orphan Werner grows up with his younger sister, enchanted by a crude radio they find. Werner becomes an expert at building and fixing these crucial new instruments, a talent that wins him a place at a brutal academy for Hitler Youth, then a special assignment to track the resistance. More and more aware of the human cost of his intelligence, Werner travels through the heart of the war and, finally, into Saint-Malo, where his story and Marie-Laure’s converge.

Last month, I was jet lagged and slept through the discussion. Thanks to Laura, our guest book club reviewer! This month, I got smart and recorded the discussion so I wouldn't miss anything.

Most everyone really liked this book. Darby led the discussion. She didn't particularly like the writing in the beginning but enjoyed it more as she got into it. She liked how the story juxtaposed the war with nature, music and art. Marie was studying the ocean snail and they go on living regardless of the damage the war was doing. Life is going to continue no matter how you try to bomb everything out, steal the art, squelch the creativity. Life is going to rise again in the grass, the flowers, the songs. Marie is so drawn to the snails.The war is not defeating them.

Diana interjected that art and music is the thing that pulls us back together after the violence. The arts are transcendent. Werner knew he should report the broadcast but he couldn't. It reminded him of his childhood and his sister. Even Volkheimer knew and was affected. He gave the rifle to Werner, "Go, take the rifle. Do what you have to do." It's speaking to humanity after all they've been through. Some were reminded of scenes from Shawshank Redemption.

What stood out to Denise was how brave Etienne became in the end. After all his post war traumatic stress, he pulled himself together and left his house to search for Marie. And, he kept looking for Marie's dad.

Darby said that the journey was more important than the ending. That as monumental as the stone had been in the beginning of the story, in the end it didn't matter whether it was in the model of the town, or the sea, or who had it. It was how the stone brought people together that was the important thing.

Every time Claire de Lune was mentioned, Carla G stopped reading and found the music on You Tube and listened to it. Most thought this book would make a great movie and everyone wanted to see the models that Marie's father made for her.

I liked the book in the beginning. I thought it had lovely language and I was intrigued by the characters and the mystery of the stone. I agreed with many of the above comments and, I too enjoyed the natural element of the story that juxtaposed the ocean and the snails showing how nature is not phased by the war.

However, about mid-way the story started to drag for me. The mystery of the stone never materialized. While Darby she was glad that the story was not about the stone but how it brought people together, I was disappointed. I wanted something more mysterious.

The story reminded me of The Book Thief in the way it was about children during the time of WWII. It reminded me of Hugo in the way that Werner tinkered with radios the way Hugo worked on the automaton. And, the ending reminded me of Cold Mountain in the way the story leads you expect the two main characters will have some kind of relationship but spend the whole book apart, and come together in the end for the briefest of moments before one of them dies. I liked it find – I just had higher hopes for it.

Subscribe to: Posts (Atom)

2015 Hosts and Books

Jan 9 - Pam Boeck - All the Light We Cannot See
Feb 6 - Lou Christian - Alif the Unseen
March 6 - Terry Cummings - Kind of Kin
April 3 - Janie Tisdale - The Girl on the Train
May 1 - Arnora Parish - The Stolen Child
Jun 5 - Barb Barrow - The Elephant Whisperer
July 10 - Diana Beal - Lone Wolf
Aug 7 - Denise McGough - The Storied Life of A.J. Fikry
Sept 11 - Sherrie Phillips - H is for Hawk
Oct 2 - Arnora Parish - The Boy Who Drew Monsters
Nov 6 - Sherrie Phillips
Dec - Laura Madden - A Child's Christmas in Wales & Christmas Day in the Morning

The Honey Tree - Mary Oliver

And so at last I climbed

the honey tree, ate

chunks of pure light, ate

the bodies of bees that could not

get out of my way, ate

the dark hair of the leaves,

the rippling bark,

the heartwood. Such

frenzy! But joy does that,

I'm told, in the beginning.

Later, maybe,

I'll come here only

sometimes and with a

middling hunger. But now

I climb like a snake

I clamber like a bear to

the nuzzling place, to the light

salvaged by the thighs

of bees and racked up

in the body of the tree.

Oh, anyone can see

how I love myself at last!

how I love the world! climbing

by day or night

in the wind, in the leaves, kneeling

at the secret rip, the cords

of my body stretching

and singing in the

heaven of appetite.

To Leave a Comment

At the end of each post you will see an option to "comment" click on that link. You'll be asked to identify yourself with either a Google email address & password or a couple of other options. If you don't have a Google account you can set one up with your current email and it only takes a minute to set up user name and password. Once you have that you can leave your comment you might be prompted to retype the security code. Your comment will automatically be posted. Process is the same if you use one of the identification options.

Lis and Diana's Review of Isaac's Storm

Lis said: This book centers around the devastating hurricane that hit Galveston, Texas, in 1901 and is blamed for the death of over 4500 people. Although the story wasn't a page-turner for most, it was full of interesting historical and scientific data while building up to describing accounts of the devastation and aftermath that the storm created. In my opinion, it is debatable whether the book should be considered a true fiction or a non-fiction. Hand in hand with the storm description, the book tells about the creation of the National Weather Service and the struggle that the organization went through to earn the people's trust. When looking back over the disaster, the author identifies areas of misuse and false pride - in the bureaucratic sector as well as the people's personal lives - that, if it had been overcome, might have averted some of the lost lives. Building up to the storm, the author touches on many historical facts surrounding the era, such as the state of Arkansas passing legislation a few decades earlier to legalize the proper pronunciation of its name to be "Arkansaw." Into this background, the author creates the characters that he was able to find in his research that made up the early Weather Service and some of the residence of Galveston, their spouses and children, making us shiver with dread over successful and unsuccessful rescue efforts. After bringing to life the unimaginable aftermath, with whole neighborhoods destroyed and bodies at every step, the book concludes with Galveston's recovery and a large chapter of Acknowledgements for the extensive support and research that the author relied on. I for one enjoyed the book immensely and, after the first third, found it difficult to put down till the end. Elisabeth Too many people put off something that brings them joy just because they haven't thought about it, don't have it on their schedule, didn't know it was coming or are too rigid to depart from their routine. I got to thinking one day about all those women on the Titanic who passed up dessert at dinner that fateful night in an effort to cut back. From then on, I've tried to be a little more flexible.

Diana said: The old saying, "hind sight is 20/20" comes to mind while reading the hurricane account of Galveston, Texas in 1901. Author Eric Larson's story reminded me of his first book we read, Devil in the White City, as he combined historical facts and real people while piecing together a plausible tale of personalities and lives. I have huge respect for writing historical fiction, as the writer not only has to devise an interesting story but also works as an investigator and researcher in the process. The first third of the story was slow and at times I found myself skimming the pages waiting for action. I think this may have been purposeful by Larson. As a reader I was going about my daily business and uninvolved like the townspeople of Galveston noting the changing winds and heading off to work. I took occasional notice of Isaac's trip to the American west by stage and his appearance as a "dandy", the use of telegraph as the primary form of communication from on location to another and it was surprising to find out the American and Cuban weather men held so little regard for each other. Americans found the Cuban forecasters primitive, romantic and unreliable. But once the hurricane was upon Galveston, I was spellbound for the remainder of the book. With the exception of once when I had to put the story down due to the brutal descriptions of decaying bodies which I found overwhelming. For me the story telling mimicked the event itself. Galveston and the rest of the U.S. were going along with business as usual, and then wham! A hurricane the magnitude no one expected or had experienced before bursts forth with action and drama and left no one untouched including me.

Lis' review of A Thousand Splendid Suns

The story playing in Afghanistan made it another compelling read and a walk through a different culture, very foreign to most of us. I had the fortune to have also read the book The Kite Runner by the same author and found that the two stories make great companion books, almost a must-read duo. Our month's selection takes us into the Arabic culture through the life of two women, one of them a servant girl's bastard child - and yes, I used the old fashioned term for illegitimate child on purpose to stay with the tone of the novel. The other woman is depicted as a well-educated, emancipated young woman from a progressive, westernized family. Through the turmoils surrounding Afghanistan's recent 30-year history, their lives intertwine with the same abusive husband and their attempt to deal with the changes brought on by the Russian occupation, the takeover of the Mujahedin and, eventually, the Taliban. The companion book, The Kite Runner, deals with the same political and social upheavals in Afghanistan but is told through the life of a man and his very devoted male servant. A Thousand Splendid Suns evoked a lot of emotion for most of us, feeling comfortable as well educated American women that have rights and can expect a certain social standing that greatly exceeds the animal-like treatment of our female Afghan counterparts under Taliban rule. Needless to say, we had a lively discussion about Afghanistan's troubles, the interactions of both women's parents' influences, their different upbringing, and how it made them relate to each other. We found similarities to the book Shanturam in this author's use of the cinema, especially Bollywood movies. One thing we did not discuss though that I found enticing, was the advantages of being able to skip hair and make-up treatments through the use of a Burka! Blue was, after all, the favored color of my youth, although I always preferred much darker shades. What do you think, ladies, Burkas in our future?

sametimenextmonth

Wednesday, January 28, 2015

January 2015 Book Club

Welcome

Internet Resources